The Concept of the Household: From Survey Design

The Concept of the Household: From Survey Design

The Concept of the Household: From Survey Design to Policy Planning Ernestina Coast, Tiziana Leone (LSE) Sara Randall (UCL) Funded by ESRC survey methods initiative Do household definitions matter? More variables being added in household section Way of measuring wealth / poverty / access to facilities which influence health

New level of analysis / explanation More use (researchers & policy makers) made of publicly available data Recognition of importance of societys basic unit as influence upon members well-being

Increasing use of indicators based on household data (e.g. MDGs, asset indicators) Increasing importance of poverty mapping which uses household level data The Issue Why does the definition matter? What are consequences of household definition? Data commissioners Data collectors Data analysts Data users Policy makers

Planning / implementing targeted interventions What are the implications for household members? Data designers & collectors have: clear ideas about why need something called household clear aims clear understanding of household definition BUT what about analysts / users / consumers far removed from collection? MIGHT: look at definition and assume this is the unit of production, consumption, socialisation central to the development process MIGHT: not even look at definition because they assume they know what a household is

We are not.. Redefining the definition of the household Methods 1. Document review (1950-present) Sub-Saharan Africa 1. Review census reports, enumerators manuals, questionnaires >1950 2. Review major household surveys since 1980 2. Key informant interviews (International) 1. 45 interviews in Tanzania, UK, USA 3. Ground truthing fieldwork (Tanzania case study) 1. Maasai area Northern Tanzania 2. Dar es Salaam 2 low income neighbourhoods 3. Rural areas: Planned for next year 4. Modelling differences, to include:

1. Female headed households 2. Household dependency ratios 3. Household size Census Data Collection: issues in household definition AIM: complete enumeration of population along with individual level characteristics for planning purposes Recurrent themes in definitions of African households Eating together Common housekeeping Living together Answerable to head Census Data Collection: issues in household definition AIM: complete enumeration of population along with individual level characteristics

for planning purposes DIFFICULTIES EVOKED Servants are they part of household or separate? Boarders / lodgers Absent household head Polygamy Complicated patterns of male female residence (Ghana) Children in boarding school Seasonal migration Census Data Collection: issues in household definition Summary: household definition is practical solution to census aims of total enumeration recognition (usually) that is a reduced social

unit recognition that compromises are made set of rules for enumerators to follow continuity over time comparability Creation of what van de Walle (2006) calls a statistical household Sample surveys: issues in household definition (eg: WFS, DHS, WHS) Household definition practical: to enable the identification of individuals for individual questionnaires The household is a device used to get at the individual. The

household is the sampling unit while the individual is the observational unit. main purpose of household questionnaire was to identify women who were eligible for the individual interview World Health Survey 2002 Zambia DHS 1992, 1996 Sample surveys: issues in household definition (eg: WFS, DHS) Much more standardised (still some local variations)

WFS left more space for interpretation Little variation between core questionnaires and those used by countries Little development over time Emphasis on comparability across time and space Interviews with data producers, collectors, users, analysts Clear distinction between the Operational household of the data collectors and the unit of analysis of the users Data collectors have very clear idea of household definition Loss of information rather minimal Not a major issue for comparative purposes Contrasting preferences when it comes to decide the focus of the definition (eg social, eating, economic)

Users not aware of definition issues The main concern is to have a survey at all Need for updated information is the strongest drive Emerging themes from interviews Single person households Urban affluent Household headship? Migrants and mobility Low-income rental neighbourhoods Occupations Mining Agribusiness Construction Defining a household=headache?

An example: A woman, whose husband lives and works in Kumasi, lives with her son, his wife and two children in one house that has two rooms. Both have their own farms, own income and make independent decisions but share the same kitchen and most days it is the mother who is cooking for the rest of the family, often using her own food crops and the son contributes meat. These two are classified as independent households and contributions to meals are recorded as respective gifts. Difficult enough but now the woman's daughter has moved in with her husband and two children for two months. No clue where they managed to squeeze in but for now most food that the mother and her son's family consume comes from the son-in-law's farm with various contributions from the two households. As the daughter's family is joining the meals, not all the farm production can be recorded as gifts.. Bjorn Schulte-Herbruggen

In depth interviewing on the concept of household Mix of cognitive interviewing and in depth Household grid sheet-flexible data collection Longido in prevalently Maasai area (9 households) Urban Dar es Saalam (23 households) An example from 2007 fieldwork in Tanzania Steven Victoria = An example from 2007 fieldwork in Tanzania Steven

Victoria = Anna Mary Joy Ernest Judy (13) An example from 2007 fieldwork in Tanzania Stevens household

Maria (13) Anna Steven Victoria = Mary Joy Ernest Judy (13)

1 Male headed household 6 adults and 9 children Dependency ratio =1.5 An example from 2007 fieldwork in Tanzania Stevens household Maria (13) Anna Steven Victoria =

Mary Joy Ernest Judy (13) 1 Male headed household 6 adults and 9 children Dependency ratio =1.5 An example from 2007 fieldwork in Longido Maria (13) Maasai

Anna Steven Sleeping last night (Census) Victoria = Mary Joy Ernest

Judy (13) 3 households: 1 male & 2 female headed 3 adults + 6 children (DR= 2) 1 woman+2 children (DR=2) 1 woman + 2 children (DR=2) An example from 2007 fieldwork in Longido Eating last night (DHS) Maria (13) Maasai Anna Steven

Victoria = Mary Joy Ernest Judy (13) 1 household: male headed 5 adults + 10 children (DR= 2) Modelling definition differences

Translated the household grid interviews into SPSS dataset We allowed for extra columns to include variables such as: Would this person make it into DHS Would this person make it into Census Created simple demographic indicators such as Dependency ratio % female headed household Household size Scenarios: from low income Dar es Salaam Whole household

Slept there last night Ate there last night Mean household size 6.83 5.71 6.13 Dependency

ratio 1.33 0.82 0.80 Sex ratio 0.74 0.73 0.59

Female HH 30% 32% 35% Summary of fieldwork experience Dar urban: very high mobility between households of children and young people Children: Instability / death of parents, get resources from somewhere else Often get resources from several different households where they may live for short periods

Young men: work mobility, sharing costs, poverty or sharing responsibility among relatives while they find a job Share some costs but not others Kin solidarity when someone has no money Summary of fieldwork experience Maasai have interdependent groups that are split up in surveys but considered by themselves to be one economic unit of production and consumption The Tanzanian definition of household Reduces the average household size Increases the proportion of female headed hhs Distorts the characteristics of

household heads Disassociates people from resources to which they have access Discussion and few thoughts Data collectors clear about what a household is, users less so Definition does matter for analysis and policy intervention Not just a matter of leaving unusual groups out Household members relationships need to be spelt out. No need to change definitions but possibly more flexible data collection? Need to think about data collection, back to the 70s?

How can we add warnings about household data for users? The household is central to the development process. Not only is the household a production unit but it is also a consumption, social and demographic unit Kenya: Ministry of Planning and National Development 2003, p59

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Apostrophe S

    Apostrophe S

    FIRST RULE. The S and apostrophe are to do with one thing owning another. Words do NOT need an apostrophe if they do not own anything. Simple plurals do not need apostrophes.
  • United States History - Polk County School District

    United States History - Polk County School District

    The diversity of religions, particularly in Rhode Island and Pennsylvania, meant that no one faith held a majority in those colonies. Therefore, no one religion became the established religion in those colonies. The American tradition of seperating church and state...
  • Making Policy in British Higher Education: how is

    Making Policy in British Higher Education: how is

    1961 the Plowden Report The Control of Public ExpenditureCmnd 1432: the creation of PESC. The Cabinet decision on public expenditure. Comprehensive Spending Reviews. The allocation process—the Dept, PES, the Star Chamber. The Browne Report and the 2010 CSR
  • Cryptography and Network Security 3/e

    Cryptography and Network Security 3/e

    Chapter 2 - Classical Encryption Techniques Classical Encryption Techniques Symmetric Encryption Or conventional / private-key / single-key sender and recipient share a common key all classical encryption algorithms are private-key was only type prior to invention of public-key in 1970's...
  • Meta-Analysis Matthew Burns University of Missouri Overview Resources

    Meta-Analysis Matthew Burns University of Missouri Overview Resources

    Random Effects Model. Articles are similar but vary somehow. There is a distribution of effect sizes. Combined effect. Fixed effects = the one common effect
  • Health & Medical Aspects Incident Management Team

    Health & Medical Aspects Incident Management Team

    Health and medical objectives at the SR 530 slide were accomplished successfully by using an all-hazards incident management approach and through outstanding cooperation between a number of different agencies. ... Health & Medical Aspects Incident Management Team
  • Parody Definition: a funny imitation Parts of Speech:

    Parody Definition: a funny imitation Parts of Speech:

    Antonym: Urban. Parts of Speech: Definition: When you think about America, you might picture New York City, but much of the country is rural, covered in trees, grass and farms. out in the country or related to the country. adjective....
  • IMPACT: Interval-based Multipass Proteomic Alignment with Constant Traceback

    IMPACT: Interval-based Multipass Proteomic Alignment with Constant Traceback

    Homogeneous substitution matrix. PE hardware resources. 1 comparator, 2 registers, 1 multiplexor. Large number of PEs can fit on a device. Increased GACT alignment throughput. Proteins. Heterogeneous substitution matrix. PE hardware resources.