Backwards Design for Long-Term Outcomes Marta Caminero-Santangelo English

Backwards Design for Long-Term Outcomes Marta Caminero-Santangelo English

Backwards Design for Long-Term Outcomes
Marta Caminero-Santangelo
English

Background
Work by Wiggins and McTigue suggests that effective
backwards design of a course considers the most
significant long-term course goalsthe enduring
questionsrather than just what is important to know.
In thinking through my course
Introduction to US Latino/a
Literature, I realized that my
assignment structure assessed
a mid-range level of outcomes
(familiarity with specific literary
texts) rather than the higherlevel understanding and skills
I really wanted students to
retain long term. For instance,
mid-terms and exams assessed
student retention of details about our analysis of particular
texts and the ways we had applied key concepts in class.
But a more important higher-level outcome, I realized, is
skills based; I want students to be able to analyze new
cultural texts they may encounter in the future (literature
but also visual images, speeches, advertisements, news
stories, songs, etc.) by applying an understanding of key
concepts they have learned about in class.

Redesign Steps

Students have found microthemes to be both less
stressful and better for their learning than exams.

1. My major innovation was that I replaced midterms and
finals with microthemesshort essays on each
individual text. These were the equivalent of essay
questions on the exams, and asked students to apply key
concepts, but also gave students greater opportunities to
independently process class discussion towards a specific
end and to formulate and organize their ideas.
2. I focused on deliberately scaffolding classroom
activities and out-of-class assignments, including group
close-reading activities during class-time to build towards
longer papers.

Microthemes are much more effective for my learning
than midterms/tests/finals. I think they actually help me
discuss what I think were the most interesting and
important things about each text. I think that because we
have microthemes instead of tests, I am more focused
on understanding patterns and themes and critically
thinking about the text because I'm not focused on
remembering small details to prepare for an exam.

Hypothesis: Students would perform better on their first
longer papers if they had been processing texts and
getting feedback on their writing with microthemes first.
Preliminary data suggests that this occurred, with
students moving up into higher range grades (many
more students getting As, and fewer getting Cs and Ds).
ENGL 337 - 2009

ENGL 337 - 2016

Paper 1 Grade
(traditional midterm)

Paper 1 Grade
(microthemes)

70.00%

70%

60.00%

60%

50.00%

50%

40.00%

40%

30.00%

30%

20.00%

20%

10.00%

10%

0.00%

A

B

C

D

F

Withdraw

0%

A

B

C

D

Because students receive my feedback on each
individual microtheme, students also learn over the
course of several microthemes how to more effectively
construct and support an analytical argument.

I honestly think microthemes as a replacement for
midterms and finals is an incredible idea. They're a great
way to see how we're processing the information and to
see what our personal takes on certain materials are. I
feel like finals and miderms wouldn't give you that
perspective on the way your students think.

Outcomes

Challenge #1: Backward Design: Reconsider the
course assignment structure so I would be asking
students to develop independent critical and analytical
skills over a more sustained period rather than assessing
primarily short-term content retention.

Because students are asked to review, process, and
apply course material immediately, this learning is
immediately reinforced (as opposed to a periodic cram
situation).

Student Feedback

3. I made the longer paper assignments more synthetic
and comparative so that students could use their
microtheme essays as potential building blocks toward
the longer essays.

Challenges

Challenge #2: Scaffolding: I felt that course
assignments could be better scaffolded to build skills.
Assignments, modeled on traditional assignment
structures in an English class, generally included two
short answer / essay exams (midterm and final) and two
longer papers. There was no discernable scaffolding that
allowed students to build skills from one kind of
assignment to another.

Reflections

Microthemes are a great alternative to a midterm or
final! Small writing assignments that I can get feedback
on and have a chance to improve before the next one is
due are better in my opinion than an in-class
essay/exam you have to cram for.

F

Withdraw

This whole microthemes as replacement for standard
memorization tests is brilliant. Short essays that I get a
day or two to think over make me actually engage with
what I learned on a personal level (as opposed to
panicked, caffeine-fueled in-class tests).

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Sciences, Education Physique Et Epistemologie

    Sciences, Education Physique Et Epistemologie

    » LAGACHE « Toute conduite motrice se manifeste par un comportement moteur, mais elle ne se réduit pas à celui-ci. Les données observables de ce comportement moteur sont en effet investies par un sens, le sens vécu de façon consciente...
  • Bridges Out of Poverty Background 1. Dr. Ruby

    Bridges Out of Poverty Background 1. Dr. Ruby

    Because of "the tyranny of the moment," an abundance of single parent households, lack of healthy role models, etc., children in poverty do not develop the "formal language register" and story structure that will help them succeed in middle class....
  • Assessment of The Costs of Homelessness in Orange County a ...

    Assessment of The Costs of Homelessness in Orange County a ...

    Objectives of Cost Study. Primary Objective: To estimate the costs of homelessness in Orange County with a focus on the cost differences between the street and sheltered homeless and those now housed in the different categories of housing -- in...
  • The Fundamentals of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)

    The Fundamentals of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)

    Jigsaw task: Mamma! What if you were trying to find long-lost family members and you had some pieces of information, but not many, to go on? Your instructor will give each student a card with information about an imaginary person...
  • Chess to built math capacity John Kunz  Started

    Chess to built math capacity John Kunz Started

    Most Chess coaches will say that focusing on tactics is the best. Most new Chess students are not very patient with the training component of a Chess program
  • Pelaksanaan Program Bacaan / Nilam

    Pelaksanaan Program Bacaan / Nilam

    - Walt Disney "Reading maketh a full man" - Francis Bacon "A wonderful thing about a book in contrast to a computer screen, is that you can take it to bed with you" - Daniel J. Boorstein " A library...
  • Curriculum district session Eastfield Funding 60x30TX Mapping budget

    Curriculum district session Eastfield Funding 60x30TX Mapping budget

    The Vice President of Instruction Council has the right, obligation and /or authority to review all curriculum revisions and /or recommendations, which may include additions, changes, modifications, etc.
  • CONTENTS Overview of the Utho Group Depth and

    CONTENTS Overview of the Utho Group Depth and

    Utho together with KR Consulting are transaction advisors assisting the MLM with a feasibility study to determine the best procurement option for electricity distribution, management and maintenance services for the municipality. ... DEVELOPMENT ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS (PTY) LTD.